She supports adults transitioning and does not suggest that post transition, those adults shouldn’t use the bathrooms or prisons reserved for their new sex. Yes she is very protective of women only spaces based on biological sex. I’ve read a lot about how “anti-trans” JKR supposedly is but I have also read the actual texts she has published on the topic. There is plenty of grey area in between but those two cases just fall onto opposite sides of a spectrum.Ĭ) the people who scream the loudest usually have no idea what they are screaming about. This is different from buying a video game based on an IP that was invented by somebody you disagree with. For example, if I buy a book written by a racist spewing racist ideology because I want to support his cause, that’s a racist act. Degrees of separation and intend do matter a lot. Easy as that.ī) I think people are going WAY too far in linking consumption and morality. Harassment makes you an asshole and concrete threats of violence or death make you a criminal.

If you want to publish that opinion and encourage others to join you, that’s also fine. If you don’t want to buy a game that’s fine. A) people are incredibly aggressive when enforcing the boycott.

Hogwarts legacy boycott fail reddit